The congregation of Bethlehem Lutheran commenced in 1879.
Our pastoral leaders have included the following:
Conrad Greed: 1879-1879, dying of a fatal disease shortly after arriving and being buried on the day scheduled for his ordination.
Carl Meyer: 1879-1883
C. Mending: 1883-1886, serving churches also in Oxford Junction and Wyoming.
J. Moehl: 1886-1899
G.J. Rembold: 1899-1904, with the Massillon parish joining for one year
H.A. Adix: 1904-1906
G.H. Vollmer: 1912-1924
Elmer Braun: 1927-1937
W.G. Weber: 1937-1946
Hans Sandrock: 1946-1947, serving Bliedhorn as well
Richard Gronewald: 1947-1952
Walter Pfeffer: 1952-1959
Robert Lehmann: 1959-1965
H.E. Dieter: 1965-1968
William Carter: 1968-1974
Rudy Wendell: 1974-1979
Dennis Wansitler: 1980-1985
Craig Bowyer: 1986-1993
Brad Miller: 1995-1996
Donnita Moeller: 1996-2000, Bethlehem began joint pastoral leadership, sharing with Oxford Junction
Keith Larson: 2001-2016
Thomas Reuss: Interim presently